The controversy over Frank McCourt's book, Angela's Ashes, continues to
rage here in Limerick and whether it reflects a true
account of his life in the city or not. As usual the first
casualty is itself truth. But perhaps there's more to the
controversy than meets the eye.
Certainly there is anecdotal evidence to suggest that there is
possibly a case to be answered by Frank McCourt for his
description of the extent of his familie's poverty while they
lived in Limerick. but to have it portrayed on national
television, by a fellow Limerickman, in the form of an
emotional outburst surely renders this evidence insubmissable
and the whole country will justly take it as begrudgeary.
However, I'd like to initiate a discussion on the fundamental
truth contained on every page of Angela's Ashes. A truth that
should justly make us proud of Frank McCourt.
This truth uses Limerick and the events of Frank McCourt's
life only as a canvas and is, I believe, why the book has sold
over 5 million copies worldwide. Within it's pages Frank
McCourt has managed to portray the fundamental truths about
the human condition. This truth is not to be found by
analysing superfically the events described in the book - the
real truth is hidden between the lines and by what is not said.
And this is where our insularity comes to the fore -the
Walls of Limerick may long since be gone but
psychologically they still stand - we have taken everything
personally. For within the pages of Angela's Ashes you will
find greed, lust, anger, jealousy, pride in fact, every deadly
sin you come to mention and they are not unique to
Limerick. For instance, the jealousy of the young man
from Easons towards the imagined carrying on of his
girlfriend, is truly frightening in it's ferocity. This event
may or may not have occured, but is it not certain that
people like those exist and more frighteningly, exist within
us all?
Perhaps the events most talked about are his treatment of
his mother and her affair with Leman Griffin. Again, why
are we so reluctant to believe this? Could it not be true? We
fain concern for Angela McCourt while castigating Frank
for talking about it. I believe it took a supreme act of
courage for him to expose to the world these events and
was a necessary thing to do in order to heal the hurt and
anger he carried with him for years. Who are we to deny
him that healing?
Only by examining our lives can we begin to grow and set
ourselves free from the bondage of our egos. Time and time
again through the pages of Angela's Ashes Frank McCourt
has done this. The book is in fact a public confession.
There is more I would like to say about this aspect of the
phenomenon of Angela's Ashes but I think there is
sufficient food for thought here. If you'd like to keep in touch with Limerick you can register here for our Newsletter.
Photos: Conor McCourt/New Video